Box office results and the quality of a movie are not the same thing.
Sometimes the marketing was lousy. Or maybe a bigger, more anticipated movie ate its lunch. Maybe audiences just didn’t show up.
Whatever the reason, these three deserved better:
1. Warrior (2011)
Warrior is one of those movies where the setup sounds more predictable than the movie actually feels.
Tom Hardy and Joel Edgerton play estranged brothers who both end up entering the same mixed martial arts tournament. Nick Nolte plays their father, a recovering alcoholic who has done enough damage to give everybody involved a reason to be angry.
So yes, you can probably see where this is heading. It doesn’t matter.
The fighting works, but the movie is really about everything these guys have been carrying around for years. Resentment. Guilt. Family. Pride. All the stuff nobody has managed to deal with.
And Nolte is terrific.
By the time the brothers finally end up where you know they’re going to end up, the movie has earned it.
The strange part is that almost nobody showed up. Warrior made roughly what it cost to produce, which is not remotely enough once marketing and theater splits are involved.
Audiences who actually watched it loved. Rotten Tomatoes has it at 92% from viewers.
2. Gattaca (1997)
Far too many people have never seen Gattaca — or even heard of it.
That’s an issue.
Ethan Hawke plays Vincent, a man born naturally in a future where genetic engineering has created a society increasingly divided between people with desirable DNA and everyone else.
Vincent wants to go to space.
His genetics disagree.
That’s basically the movie, although there’s a lot more going on around it, including Jude Law giving one of his best performances and a murder investigation that adds just enough tension without taking over the story.
This is science fiction without constantly reminding you that it’s science fiction. No giant battles. No endless effects. Just a very good idea, a very good cast, and a story about refusing to let somebody else decide what you’re capable of.
It bombed anyway.
The audience score is now 87% on Rotten Tomatoes.
Apparently people just needed a little more time.
3. The Shawshank Redemption (1994)
This one still feels almost impossible to me.
One of my favorite movies ever made — maybe my favorite — was a box-office bomb. And it’s a movie that takes place almost entirely inside a prison.
That sounds absurd, but The Shawshank Redemption has become one of the most beloved movies ever made. It has spent years near or at the top of IMDb’s rankings and routinely shows up on greatest-movies-ever lists.
I understand why.
Yes, it’s bleak. There’s brutality, corruption and years of a man’s life disappearing behind prison walls. But what people love about the movie is the friendship, the hope, and Andy’s refusal to let the place define him.
And the ending?
Best movie ending I’ve ever seen.
Audiences eventually caught up. Rotten Tomatoes now has it at an almost unheard-of 98% from viewers, with more than 250,000 ratings.
Not bad for a prison movie nobody showed up for.
There is a useful lesson here.
Opening weekend tells you how successfully a movie was sold.
It does not necessarily tell you how good the movie is.
Sometimes audiences figure that part out years later.
These 3 Movies Bombed. They're Still Worth Watching.
A bad box-office run doesn’t always mean a bad movie. Some excellent films found their audience only after theaters had already given up on them.
Read article
