Most crime thrillers wait until dark to make things uncomfortable. Insomnia sends Al Pacino to an Alaskan town where the sun barely sets, then leaves him trying to solve a murder without getting any sleep.

And Robin Williams isn’t going to make his visit any more pleasant.

If you mostly remember Williams as somebody who made you laugh, this is a good opportunity to see how uncomfortable he could make you.

What It’s About

Pacino plays Will Dormer, a veteran Los Angeles detective sent to help investigate the murder of a teenage girl. His reputation arrives ahead of him, particularly with Ellie Burr (Hilary Swank), a young local officer who has studied his work and is eager to learn from him.

Dormer knows how to work a case. But he’s brought problems from Los Angeles, and the constant daylight makes it increasingly difficult to get the rest he needs.

The investigation leads toward Walter Finch (Williams), a local novelist whose connection to the case becomes a growing concern. As the two men become entangled, Dormer finds himself dealing with someone who pays very close attention to his weaknesses.

Meanwhile, Ellie is paying attention, too.

Who It’s For

The appeal here is watching capable actors make a conversation feel dangerous. Williams plays Finch with a calm, almost reasonable manner that makes you listen more carefully to what he’s actually saying. His familiarity makes the performance especially unnerving.

Pacino looks exhausted, but he also shows you what that exhaustion does: patience wears thin, concentration slips, and decisions become harder to trust. Swank gives Ellie enough intelligence and determination that her admiration for Dormer never makes her seem foolish.

Christopher Nolan keeps the pressure building through the investigation and the increasingly uncomfortable relationship between Dormer and Finch. There’s action, but much of the tension comes from wondering what somebody knows and what they intend to do with it.

It’s grim, deliberate and worth your attention if you enjoy crime stories where catching someone is only part of the problem.

 

Al Pacino is running on fumes, and Robin Williams is quietly making things worse. This is an unsettling thriller built around two men who have very good reasons to worry about each other.