Some people look forward to Christmas all year. Others would just as soon skip the whole thing.

In The Holdovers, three people find themselves stuck at a nearly empty boarding school over the holidays, and none of them is particularly happy about it.

It doesn't sound like much of a Christmas celebration, but it turns out to be the beginning of a pretty good story.

What It’s About

It's December 1970 at Barton Academy, an exclusive New England boarding school where the students are preparing to head home for Christmas.

Unfortunately, not everyone gets to leave.

Paul Giamatti plays Paul Hunham, a history teacher who's about as popular with his students as a surprise exam. He's demanding, sarcastic, and apparently incapable of making himself agreeable to anyone.

When he's assigned to supervise the students who can't go home for Christmas, he's no happier about the arrangement than they are.

One of those students is Angus Tully (Dominic Sessa), a bright but rebellious teenager whose mother has decided to spend the holidays with her new husband instead of her son.

Also staying behind is Mary Lamb (Da'Vine Joy Randolph), the school's cook, who's grieving the loss of her son in Vietnam.

As the holiday break unfolds, these three very different people begin to discover that they have more in common than they might have imagined.

Who It’s For

If you enjoy movies built around interesting characters rather than elaborate plots, The Holdovers is worth your attention.

Giamatti is excellent as a thoroughly unpleasant man who gradually reveals there's more to him than his disagreeable personality. His exchanges with Sessa are particularly entertaining, and the young actor holds his own remarkably well.

Randolph brings something different to the movie. Her character's grief is never far from the surface, even during the lighter moments, and she gives the story much of its emotional weight.

The movie takes its time, and there's a slightly old-fashioned quality to it that suits the 1970 setting. The humor comes naturally from the characters, while the more serious moments generally avoid becoming overly sentimental.

Don't expect a traditional Christmas comedy. This is a quieter, more thoughtful movie about loneliness, disappointment, and the unexpected connections people sometimes make.

It's the kind of movie that doesn't need much to happen to keep you interested.

 

Three people who would rather be somewhere else find themselves spending Christmas together. Paul Giamatti leads a terrific cast in a movie that's funny, occasionally sad, and surprisingly touching.