A movie about a married couple performing Neil Diamond songs at bars and local events doesn't exactly sound like the foundation for a big emotional drama.

That's part of what makes Song Sung Blue interesting.

The music gets you in the door, Hugh Jackman and Kate Hudson make the couple easy to spend time with, and then the movie gradually reveals that there's considerably more going on here than two people singing "Sweet Caroline."

What It’s About

Song Sung Blue is based on the true story of Mike and Claire Sardina, two struggling Milwaukee musicians who meet, fall in love and create a Neil Diamond tribute act called Lightning & Thunder. The movie itself was adapted from Greg Kohs' 2008 documentary about the couple.

Hugh Jackman plays Mike, a performer convinced that he has something more to offer than the impersonation gigs he's been doing. Kate Hudson is Claire, a single mother and singer who quickly becomes both his musical partner and, eventually, his wife.

Together they discover that they're actually pretty good at this. Their act starts attracting attention, and for a while Song Sung Blue has the feel of one of those enjoyable movies about ordinary people getting an unexpected shot at something bigger.

But their story isn't remotely that simple.

Life keeps interfering with the dream, and the movie becomes as much about their relationship and their ability to keep going as it is about music.

Who It’s For

You don't need to be a Neil Diamond fanatic to enjoy this. It helps if you like his music, obviously, but the songs aren't really the point. Mike and Claire are.

Jackman is naturally comfortable playing a guy who comes alive in front of an audience, but Hudson is arguably the bigger reason the movie works. She gives Claire an easy warmth without making her feel like the generic supportive wife in somebody else's story.

Be aware that Song Sung Blue gets considerably heavier than its cheerful musical premise suggests. There are some substantial tonal swings, and at 2 hours and 12 minutes, it could have been tighter. Critics were somewhat divided on how well the melodrama works, while audiences responded much more enthusiastically. Rotten Tomatoes currently has it at 77% from critics and 97% from verified audiences.

 

Hugh Jackman and Kate Hudson turn the true story of a Milwaukee Neil Diamond tribute act into something considerably more substantial than the premise suggests.